Nitai Zori, Hillel Zori and Dror Semmel perform Schubert Trios Op.99 and Op.100 on period instruments at the Eden-Tamir Music Center, Jerusalem

Nitai Zori, Dror Semmel, Hillel Zori (Shirley Burdick)

On May 24th 2025, the auditorium of the Eden-Tamir Music Center, Ein Kerem, Jerusalem, was packed to capacity for a festive event - a concert of chamber music featuring the center's newest acquisition - a Graf fortepiano.  Performing the all-Schubert program were artistic director of the Eden-Tamir Music Center Dror Semmel (fortepiano), Nitai Zori (violin) and Hillel Zori ('cello).

 

In January 2025, Paul McNulty (USA-Czech Republic), celebrated for his meticulous craftsmanship and expertise in the building of historical fortepianos, arrived in Jerusalem to add the final adjustments to the newly-crafted instrument now making its home at the Eden-Tamir Music Center. The Graf fortepiano, handcrafted from walnut and modelled after instruments used by Beethoven, Schubert, and Chopin, bridges the past to the present, offering musicians and audiences an authentic glimpse into the soundscapes of classical music’s golden era. The addition of the McNulty Graf fortepiano not only enriches the Eden-Tamir Center's concert repertoire; it also underscores the center's commitment to preserving and promoting historical performance practice and to attracting musicians, scholars and audiences eager to experience the rich sounds of the fortepiano's heyday. This is the only Graf fortepiano in Israel.

 

Opening the event, Dr. Dror Semmel expressed his appreciation to the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Foundation for its support in the purchase of the instrument. All three of the performing artists spoke about the instruments they would be playing. Semmel spoke of the acoustic properties of the fortepiano. The string players referred to historic bows.  Hillel Zori played on a Baroque 'cello (Amit Tiefenbrunn), whereas Nitai Zori was playing a period Classical violin. Both were playing on gut strings. 

 

The program comprised Franz Schubert's Piano Trio in B flat major Op.99 and Piano Trio No.2 in E flat major Op.100. It is possible that Schubert composed these two monumental piano trios close together in late 1827, the year before his death, although it remains unclear in what order they were written. Work on them seems to have taken place simultaneously with that on "Die Winterreise", the trios providing a lighter project to divert Schubert’s attention from the illness and melancholy that was preoccupying him in the last months of his life. 

 

Opening with Op.99, the artists had the audience at the edge of its seats, with playing that gave clean, articulate expression to the work's sparkling, buoyant writing, to its lyrical sweep and melodic inventiveness and to Schubert’s use of modulation and the changing of keys to vary the presentation, treatment and tone colour of his themes. Following the bold, intense gestures of the opening Allegro moderato, we were lured into the personal discourse and gorgeous songful theme expressed so tenderly in the second movement (Andante un poco mosso), perhaps a graceful façade for the doubts and the anguish of a Schubert no more than a few months off death. Then, following the playful, good-natured Scherzo with its coy Trio, the Viennese melodiousness of the Rondo reasserted the blitheness of the first movement, with Schubert's distinctive tremolos in the piano, these adding an air of mystery and a wistful flutter of heart. 

 

Robert Schumann considered Schubert's two great trios a complementary pair - the B-flat, more lyrical; the E-flat, more robust. Indeed, it was Schumann who hailed the E-flat trio as "an angry meteor blazing forth and outshining everything in the musical atmosphere of the time."  The artists' inspired playing of the Allegro, its opening unison motif bold, the second theme peaceful, emerged in a myriad of meticulously shaped phrases, the Schubert-style keyboard arpeggios fetchingly delicate, then to build up dramatically. Following the Andante con moto, one of Schubert's most haunting melodies, cast over a quasi funeral-march rhythm, its stormy outbursts punctuated by general calm and mysterious gestures, the contrapuntally elegant, lightly-tripping Allegro takes flight. The Allegro moderato (final) movement bears eloquent (indeed nostalgic) witness to the cohesion and cyclic element of this panoramic work. And there it was - that striking, heart-stopping moment in the finale where Schubert brings back the funeral music, the movement's conclusion then to twist into the major key. The artists played the full, original version of the 4th movement.

 

From their playing and close communication, one is aware of the fact that Semmel and the Zori brothers have collaborated much in the performance of chamber music. With commitment and compelling emotional involvement, they addressed- and presented every nuance of these two tremendous piano trios on period instruments - the sound world familiar to Schubert. Not to be ignored was the dynamic range of the instruments, the splendid copy of the 1819 fortepiano sounding crystal-clear and true (with Semmel skilfully bringing into play the unique tonal qualities implemented by the instrument's tricky pedal system.) 

Graf fortepiano (Courtesy Dr. Dror Semmel)